52% of evangelical leaders think that Jesus would make a lousy evangelical

by Rachel Held Evans Read Distraction Free
Wine Glass In Focus IIphoto © 2007 James Williams | more info (via: Wylio)

Since so many of us either came from or continue to identify with the evangelical religious culture, I thought it might be interesting to discuss the results of a pew forum study released last week. The survey polled over 2,000 evangelical leaders worldwide. Some of the more notable results include: 


  • 75 percent of responders favored allowing women to serve as pastors
  • 79 percent believe that men should be the religious leaders in the marriage and family
  • 53 percent believe men should be the main financial providers for the family


  • 84 percent of responders said that “society should discourage homosexuality” 


  • 96 percent said that abortion is usually or always wrong

The Prosperity Gospel…

  • 90 percent of responders said that God does not always give wealth and health to people of faith
  • Only 7 percent endorsed the “prosperity gospel”


  • 47 percent believe that humans have existed in their current form since the beginning of time
  • 41 percent believe that evolution occurred, guided by God


  • 82 percent of U.S. evangelical leaders think their influence is declining
  • However, 58 percent of evangelicals in the global south (Africa, Asia and Latin America) see their influence as increasing

The Bible…

  • 98 percent agreed that the Bible is the word of God
  • 50 percent said that the Bible should be taken literally, word-for-word

 What is essential to be a good evangelical?...

  • 97 percent said following the teachings of Christ in one's personal and family life
  • 94 percent said leading others to Christ
  • 73 percent said helping the poor and needy


  • 52 percent said that drinking alcohol is not compatible with being a good evangelical
  • 42 percent said that drinking alcohol is compatible with being a good evangelical.


My thoughts: I was pleasantly surprised by the growing acceptance of female pastors and what appears to be a consensus against the prosperity gospel. I also loved that alleviating poverty made it to the "essentials" list. 

Regarding homosexuality, I suspect that if the same poll is taken in 10 years, the number will decrease dramatically. (Of all the “issues” reflected in the poll, I think this one is the most generational.)

Regarding alcohol, I think it’s funny that 52 percent of evangelicals think that Jesus would make a lousy one! 

Check out the survey for more fascinating results

So what from this survey most captured your interest? What did you find encouraging/discouraging? 

Do your views align with those of most evangelical leaders? Do you identify yourself as an evangelical?

End of article logo.

Shareable Permalink

© 2011 All rights reserved.
Copying and republishing this article on other Web sites without written permission is prohibited.
Browse articles with tags: evangelicalismfaith